Podcasts:

BWD IN THE KNOW | EPISODE 29

Posted on
February 28, 2025
Posted by
James Walker

The Recruitment Industry’s Biggest Lie... & Why Clients Keep Falling for It

Recruitment has been running on fumes for years. The contingent model dominates, yet it delivers an 80% chance of wasted time.

Louise Archer and I dug into why the industry clings to it, despite better alternatives. 

Some key takeaways:

  • Retained search isn’t just for execs in pinstripe suits—it’s a better way to recruit across the board.
  • Clients often think contingent is faster and cheaper, but the reality? It’s slow, inefficient, and costs more in the long run.
  • The biggest issue? A lack of education. Louise shared a story about a senior HR leader who spent 15 years rejecting retained search—until she finally had it explained properly. Now, she’s one of their top retained billers.
  • AI will eat low-level, high-volume hiring. For recruiters to survive, they need to move up the value chain—retained search is the future.

Thanks to Louise for a great conversation!

So, is it time to stop treating recruitment like a gamble? 


▶Dive into the strategic insights:

Apple Podcast | Spotify | YouTube | Website

BWD IN THE KNOW | EPISODE 29

Related Articles

There’s a reason clients stay with us: we deliver